Heat Stroke vs Heat Exhaustion: Recognition and Field Treatment

Heat-related illnesses kill more people than all other weather events combined. In the wilderness, without air conditioning or immediate medical care, understanding the progression from heat cramps to heat stroke can save lives. Recognition and rapid cooling make the difference.

The Heat Illness Spectrum

Heat illness progresses through predictable stages:

  1. Heat Cramps → 2. Heat Exhaustion → 3. Heat Stroke (FATAL)

Understanding this progression helps you intervene before it becomes critical.

Heat Exhaustion vs Heat Stroke: Critical Differences

Heat Exhaustion (URGENT but not immediately fatal):

  • Core temp: 99-104°F (37-40°C)
  • Mental status: Alert but fatigued
  • Skin: SWEATING profusely, clammy
  • Can still cool themselves: Yes

Heat Stroke (MEDICAL EMERGENCY – Fatal without treatment):

  • Core temp: >104°F (>40°C)
  • Mental status: ALTERED (confused, aggressive, unconscious)
  • Skin: HOT and DRY (sweating stopped) OR still sweating
  • Can still cool themselves: NO—thermoregulation failed

KEY DISTINCTION: Mental status changes = HEAT STROKE

Recognizing Heat Exhaustion

Early Warning Signs:

  • Excessive sweating
  • Fatigue and weakness
  • Headache
  • Nausea
  • Muscle cramps
  • Dizziness
  • Rapid pulse

Progressive Symptoms:

  • Vomiting
  • Pale, clammy skin
  • Fainting
  • Decreased urine output
  • Irritability
  • Goosebumps despite heat

Field Treatment:

  1. Stop all activity immediately
  2. Move to coolest available area (shade, water, elevation)
  3. Remove excess clothing
  4. Active cooling:
    • Wet and fan continuously
    • Ice packs to neck, armpits, groin
    • Immerse in cool water if available
  5. Hydrate aggressively:
    • Small, frequent sips
    • Add electrolytes
    • 1-2 liters over first hour
  6. Monitor closely – Can progress to heat stroke

Recognizing Heat Stroke

Classic Heat Stroke (gradual onset):

  • Elderly or chronically ill
  • Hot, dry, flushed skin
  • Develops over days
  • Often during heat waves

Exertional Heat Stroke (rapid onset):

  • Young, fit individuals
  • May still be sweating
  • Develops in hours
  • During intense activity

Universal Signs:

  • Altered mental status (hallucinations, aggression, confusion)
  • Core temp >104°F
  • Rapid, strong pulse
  • Throbbing headache
  • Loss of coordination
  • Seizures
  • Unconsciousness

Heat Stroke: Emergency Field Treatment

COOL FIRST, TRANSPORT SECOND

Immediate Actions:

  1. Call for emergency evacuation
  2. Begin aggressive cooling NOW
  3. Don’t wait for helicopter

Aggressive Cooling Methods (Use ALL available):

Ice Water Immersion (Most Effective):

  • Immerse to neck in cold water
  • Add ice if available
  • Stir water constantly
  • Monitor airway if unconscious
  • Remove when shivering starts

Evaporative Cooling:

  • Strip patient
  • Douse with water continuously
  • Fan vigorously (creates evaporation)
  • Focus on high blood-flow areas

Ice Packing:

  • Neck, armpits, groin (major arteries)
  • Rotate ice packs frequently
  • Don’t apply directly to skin

Improvised Methods:

  • Wet sleeping bag evaporation
  • Stream immersion
  • Snow/ice if available
  • Wet towel rotation
  • Alcohol wipes (evaporate quickly)

Cooling Goals:

  • Reduce to 102°F (39°C)
  • Then slow cooling to prevent overshoot
  • Monitor for shivering (stop cooling)
  • Resume if temperature rises

Special Considerations

Wilderness Challenges:

  • No IV fluids available
  • No core temperature monitoring
  • Limited cooling resources
  • Delayed evacuation
  • Must prevent relapse

Hydration Paradox:

  • Heat stroke victims often can’t absorb oral fluids
  • Vomiting common
  • May need rectal fluids (last resort)
  • Small, frequent sips if conscious
  • Don’t force fluids if altered mental status

Prevention Strategies

Acclimatization:

  • Takes 10-14 days
  • Start with short exposures
  • Gradually increase intensity
  • Critical for safety

Hydration Protocol:

Before activity:

  • 500ml two hours before
  • 250ml immediately before

During activity:

  • 200-300ml every 20 minutes
  • Don’t wait for thirst
  • Include electrolytes

After activity:

  • 150% of fluid lost
  • Monitor urine color

Risk Factors:

Individual:

  • Age extremes (young and old)
  • Obesity
  • Poor fitness
  • Previous heat illness
  • Medications (antihistamines, antidepressants)
  • Alcohol use
  • Dehydration

Environmental:

  • High humidity (sweat won’t evaporate)
  • No wind
  • Direct sun exposure
  • Heavy clothing/gear
  • Altitude

The Danger Zone: Wet Bulb Temperature

When humidity prevents sweat evaporation:

  • 95°F + 100% humidity = Fatal
  • 104°F + 50% humidity = Dangerous
  • 115°F + 30% humidity = Limit activity

Check heat index, not just temperature

Complications to Monitor

During Cooling:

  • Shivering (stop cooling temporarily)
  • Seizures (protect from injury)
  • Vomiting (maintain airway)
  • Combativeness (may need restraint)

After Initial Recovery:

  • Organ failure (kidneys, liver)
  • Rhabdomyolysis (muscle breakdown)
  • DIC (blood clotting disorder)
  • Permanent brain damage

ALL heat stroke victims need hospitalization

Group Management

When one person has heat illness:

  • Others likely affected
  • Check entire group
  • Modify plans for everyone
  • Consider evacuation for all
  • Prevent "summit fever" decisions

Recovery Timeline

Heat Exhaustion:

  • 24-48 hours with proper treatment
  • No activity next day
  • Increased susceptibility for weeks

Heat Stroke:

  • Life-threatening for days
  • Weeks to months full recovery
  • Permanent organ damage possible
  • Increased heat sensitivity lifelong

Creating Shade and Cooling

Improvised Shade:

  • Tarp lean-to
  • Reflective space blanket
  • Natural features
  • Dig into hillside
  • Create air flow

Improvised Cooling:

  • Wet bandanas on pulse points
  • Feet in stream
  • Wet hat
  • Spray bottle
  • Battery-powered fan

Warning Signs to Evacuate

Heat Exhaustion:

  • Not improving after 30 minutes
  • Vomiting prevents hydration
  • Altered mental status developing
  • Temperature still rising

Heat Stroke:

  • ALWAYS evacuate
  • This is a critical care emergency
  • Permanent damage occurring
  • Fatal without hospital care

Common Myths Debunked

Myth: Only out-of-shape people get heat stroke
Truth: Elite athletes commonly affected

Myth: If still sweating, not heat stroke
Truth: 50% of heat stroke victims still sweat

Myth: Drinking water prevents all heat illness
Truth: Cooling is equally important

Myth: Salt tablets prevent heat illness
Truth: Can worsen dehydration

Myth: Beer hydrates in heat
Truth: Alcohol accelerates dehydration

Regional Considerations

Desert:

  • Start hiking before dawn
  • Rest 10am-4pm
  • Carry minimum 1 gallon/day
  • Light colored, loose clothing

Humid Tropics:

  • Sweat won’t evaporate
  • Heat illness at lower temperatures
  • Frequent cooling breaks
  • Accept slower pace

High Altitude:

  • Increased dehydration
  • Sun intensity higher
  • Combined with altitude sickness
  • Extra vigilance required

The Golden Rules

  1. Confusion = Heat Stroke until proven otherwise
  2. Cool first, evacuate second
  3. Prevent is easier than treat
  4. When in doubt, stop and cool
  5. Group safety over summit goals

The Bottom Line

Heat stroke is a true emergency where minutes matter. Your rapid recognition and aggressive cooling in the field can prevent death and permanent disability. But remember: heat illness is 100% preventable with proper preparation, pacing, and the wisdom to turn back when your body says stop.

The summit will be there tomorrow. You might not be if you ignore heat illness today.

Scroll to Top